Robert Myles
English 1a
Formal paper 2: Persuasive Judgment
May 29,2013
Dear, Santa Cruz Community,
When was the last
time you ever walked into a place were you felt like you didn’t belong or you
were a total outsider? Or a time
where you felt like your presence around a certain group of people didn’t feel
right? Unfortunately for some of my teammates and I go through this more often
than some since we live in a more Caucasian dominate area. There times were we
go into stores and restaurants in the community and people instantly stop and
look at us like they never seen African Americans before. We sometimes guess to
see if they instantly began to judge us based off our looks and appearance,
which brings me to my topic about judgment and stereotypes. In my paper I will attempt to persuade
Caucasian American people in my community not to judge other races base off
their appearance & stereotypical beliefs.
Judging
someone by their appearance can lower their self-esteem according to Melanie
J.V. Fennell “low self-esteem is a core beliefs, anxious predictions and self
criticism that appears to be an reflection of central negative beliefs.” Being judge in a negative way can
result into lowering ones self-esteem. For example possibly saying or giving
the vibe that a person doesn’t belong can make that person feel unwanted or
less important. When doing so they start to feel lesser of themselves and cause
their behavior to change negatively in way that they will go out and do things
out of character. I know for me when I feel that I’m not welcome or don’t
belong in a certain place I tend to leave and be alone. When I was younger I
was the type to walk around my household with an attitude towards my siblings
or starts fights with them when I felt down about myself. It was an unusual
emotion and behavior for me because I was always a happy and full of enjoyment
kid, so when I would act this way my parents always know something was wrong.
In
Santa Cruz County population is estimated at 266,776 people in 2012. The percentage
of African American is 1.4 percent. The Caucasian American percentage in Santa
Cruz is 88.0. According to the US Census Bureau. Theses statistics clearly show
that there are hardly y any African American people who live in Santa Cruz;
therefore, people who live here all year long aren’t used to African Americans.
When Caucasians see African Americans they tend to judge based on what they see
or hear on television. Television tends to show that some African Americans are
thugs, rappers, and criminals.
However, not all
television shows portrays stereotypes of African Americans. For example the
show “Love and Hip-Hop” shows that African American rappers have a
thug/Gangster image and tend to commit crimes behind the scenes. But some truth
to it is that some who does but not all. Cast star Rapper Joe Budden, who’s
very intelligent and has a very broad vocabulary isn’t a criminal. He raps
about his personal life situations that he learned from early on in his life
and shares it with his fans so that they won’t make the mistakes he did.
Another co-star, who is a writer/producer by the name Consequence, is also very
smart and family oriented man. He put his wife and son first before his career.
His wife of three years happens to be a Caucasian female in Queens, NY. This is
an example of two people from different race who don’t discriminate based on
color or race and are still able to find love for each other to have a kid and
be married. They changed their view because they started to see that love is
much more than skin deep. Television shows like this are important because the
white audience need to see that not all blacks are exactly what they see on
other shows or movies. There are black people who do a lot of good and are very
successful.
As an African American
student Basketball player in a primarily dominant Caucasian community, I
instant look at myself as an outcast. I watch my every move because I’m not
sure who’s watching me or what the people around me are thinking. I’m from Las Vegas a city where there’s
an even balance of people from all different races so, its normal to be around
those who don’t look the same way as you. By that it benefits the society
because people feel more welcome to be who they are and not be something
they’re not. If people in a different city with a lot more people and various
races can walk the same streets and shop at the same store can do it without
judging the next person to walk by then people in Santa Cruz can do it too. It
matters to me because it shows not every place is the same. Some or better and
others are worst, but other place can change it and improve like the Santa Cruz
community can.
People in Santa
Cruz should be more open to others that way its easier to get people to want to
come and stay rather than come and get the vibe that Santa Cruz isn’t the place
for them. Also if people were to be more open with accepting others people
around town wouldn’t seem so depressed. Likewise many people who hangout
downtown Santa Cruz like the homeless tend to walk around like the world is
over from others staring and pointing as if they came from a different planet.
I’ve talked to several people down there and they are nice and fun to talk to.
They have interesting stories and views of life, but they think others look at them
as psychos.
In the article “My
Heart Is As Black As Yours” it talks about how Mario Procaccio a state senate
candidate unintentionally insulted the black community by saying that “My Heart
Is As Black As Yours.” The Black community took his words as disrespect.
Reporters called his campaign group “Anti Blacks and Racist” groups. This a example
when misjudgment of the Black community goes wrong. Procaccio thought he understood
what the black community was going through and put it in words, which stated “Elect me and I will put Blacks in
their right place.” that Black community didn’t agree with his choice words. In
this situation Procaccio speech was intended to help crime prevention. This
goes to show why you shouldn’t judge a Ethnic community before speaking on a
situation because you never know how one may react to it. For example George
Wallace an opined southern segregationist said, “it’s something you would hear in Alabama but with a New York
accent.” In other words Procaccio’s campaign is nothing more than indirect form
of bigotry.
My teammates and I
travel around the Santa Cruz area and get the feeling of being judged every
time. When we walk into the Safeway grocery store we get the stare as if we are
going to steal. Personally when I walk up and down isles and I see workers
following I instantly get irritated. I get to the point where I don’t want to
shop anymore and I’d rather send other people into do my shopping for me. After
I leave I feel like I’m never welcome into the store. People stop and stare for
long periods of time and it bothers my African American teammates and I a lot. If
people were nicer and didn’t look at me like the stereotypical African American
guy they see on television then I’d be more than happy and feel comfortable
grocery shopping there all the times. It’s times when we walk into the store
and the vibe from the people in the store is negative. That makes me resort to
having to go grocery shopping at midnight, when there’s hardly any workers and
no other customers. Being friendly and not quick to assume/judge can easily
eliminate this feeling for most African Americans and not just us.
I personally feel
if people were to take the time out to get to know someone before assuming/
judging who they would have a more positive affect on the people they meet. For
example if one of the workers were to ask me how I was doing or where I from,
just small talk whenever I come into the store then I’d feel a lot better when
I come and go into the store. This also can make me or anyone else whose going
through this feel better when going into a grocery store during the day when
its possibly busy and not at night when its empty.
My argument here
is people shouldn’t judge because it drives people away from a good opportunity.
It makes them feel bad about themselves in a way it can cause them to react
from it in a negative way. To judge without any information about someone
should be irrelevant to any situation.
You never know a good person can walk up and be the best person they can
be but thinking of them differently may cause them to go away. Some things as
simple as a smile can go a long way to make someone feel welcome.
In conclusion I’ve
gave my insight and suggestions on how being judgmental can be affective and
make someone feel who comes from a completely different area have low
self-esteem and feel unwanted. I
gave my information about how the media stereotypes can portray African
Americans to being something that they’re not but in reality being just like
everyone else that is smart well educated and family oriented. After reading
this I hope the people in the Santa Cruz can become more open to meeting people
who aren’t from this area, to make them feel more comfortable and welcome of
being in a nice area to better themselves and be around things they aren’t
usually use to being around. Also I hope the readers understand my views and
suggestion of shopping at Safeway make it a better store for all people to shop
at and feel welcome.
Work Cited
"Santa Cruz County QuickFacts from
the US Census Bureau." Santa Cruz County QuickFacts from the US Census
Bureau. Quick Facts, 11 Mar. 2013. Web. 25 May 2013.
V. Fennell, Melanie J. "Low
Self-Esteem - Springer." Low Self-Esteem - Springer. Encyclopedia
of Cognitive Behavior Therapy, 2005. Web. 25 May 2013.
Lizzi, Maria C. "My
Heart Is a S Black as Yours"" Web.ebscohost.com.
Journal of American
Ethnic History, Spring 2008.
Web. May 11